Himachal High Court: denying study leave to staff nurses while allowing doctors is discriminatory
The High Court quashed the State's refusal for two regularised nurses, saying it defies logic to allow doctors postgraduate study leave but not nurses.

Key Takeaways
- 1The High Court quashed the State's refusal for two regularised nurses, saying it defies logic to allow doctors postgraduate study leave but not nurses.
Listen to this Article
Narrated by system voice
SHIMLA — The Himachal Pradesh High Court has held that refusing study leave to staff nurses for postgraduate nursing, while Medical Officers can get it as in-service candidates, is “highly discriminatory”. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua quashed a State decision and ordered No Objection Certificates (NOCs) and study leave for two nurses admitted to M.Sc Nursing for 2026-27, according to the judgment, which LiveLaw and Medical Dialogues reported.
The ruling in brief
The judgment in CWP Nos. 18264 and 18266 of 2026 was decided on 15 October 2026, going by the order published by LiveLaw. The court allowed both writ petitions, set aside the State’s communication of 3 October 2026 and directed that all formalities be completed within one week, on or before 22 October 2026. A writ petition is a direct request to the High Court to correct a decision of the government.
The petitioners and the facts
The petitioners, Archna Thakur and Haseena Kumari, were selected as Staff Nurses in the Health Department and appointed on contract on 19 May 2021. Their services were regularised on 10 November 2023. After Atal Medical and Research University, Himachal Pradesh, issued a prospectus for M.Sc Nursing on 16 July 2026, provisional NOCs were issued to them on 23 July to take part in selection as in-service candidates. The result came on 14 September, and both nurses succeeded and were allotted seats through counselling among in-service candidates.
They applied for fresh NOCs and study leave on 26 September. The State’s letter of 3 October declined both, yet approved NOCs and study leave for eight other Staff Nurses, the judgment records. The letter gave no reason, the court noted. The nurses’ counsel said they understood the refusal was because they lacked five years of regular service, with contractual years not counted.
The State’s stand
In office instructions dated 14 October 2026, which the State asked the court to treat as its stand, the Health Department argued that study leave is governed by Rule 50 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972. It said an earlier ruling on Ayurvedic Medical Officers, Geetika Dharmani, did not apply because those petitioners studied courses directly connected with their duties. It also pointed out that Rule 50 lets a Medical Officer take postgraduate study leave if the Director General of Health Services certifies it will improve efficiency, and said Staff Nurses “cannot equate themselves with the Medical Officers”.
What the court reasoned
The court first noted the State did not dispute that the nurses had five years of service counting contractual and regular years. It relied on Geetika Dharmani (decided 27 July 2023) and on Shailja Sharma v. State of H.P. (decided 11 December 2025), where Staff Nurses seeking M.Sc Nursing study leave had also been refused for lacking five years of regular service.
On the doctor-nurse comparison, Justice Dua wrote that if a Medical Officer can be granted study leave for a postgraduate course, “it defies logic as to why a nurse cannot be granted study leave” for a postgraduate nursing course. If a doctor’s postgraduate degree advances public interest, “the same analogy would also hold good” for nurses, the judge held, adding that a welfare State could not discriminate between the two cadres when both study in their own streams. As eight Staff Nurses had been cleared for the same course, denial to the petitioners was “beyond comprehension”.
The directions
The State was directed to grant NOCs and study leave to both nurses as in-service candidates for the 2026-27 M.Sc Nursing session at Atal Medical and Research University, with formalities done by 22 October. Classes at the allotted college were scheduled to begin on 21 October, and the court had earlier, on 12 October, ordered the two seats kept vacant for the petitioners.
Study leave rules in plain terms
According to the published text of the CCS (Leave) Rules, Rule 50(5) requires an employee to have completed probation and rendered “not less than five years’ regular continuous service”, to be more than three years from retirement on return, and to sign a bond to serve the government for three years afterwards. Rule 51 ordinarily caps study leave at twelve months at a time and 24 months over a whole career, with up to 36 months for Central Health Service officers pursuing a postgraduate qualification. These are the central rules the State cited; this report has not seen Himachal’s own amendments, which the 3 October letter says apply.
How it compares with doctors
The Rule 50 proviso names Medical Officers and postgraduate study in Medical Sciences, with a certificate from the Director General of Health Services. The State read that as excluding nurses. The court did not accept that reading as a basis for treating nurses differently in practice, because the State had already approved eight nurses for the same degree.
What it means for nurses seeking higher study
Two points matter to in-service nurses in Himachal. Contractual service followed by regularisation can count toward the five-year requirement, as the court applied it. And a refusal that treats nurses differently from similarly placed staff, without reasons, can be challenged. This is a High Court order on two petitioners, and nurses elsewhere should check their own state service rules.
What is not yet known
None of the sources fetched says whether the State will appeal, or whether the nurses joined their classes on time. The reports also do not say how many M.Sc Nursing seats are reserved for in-service candidates, and this report does not give that figure.
Get the brief that 12,000+ nurses read every Tuesday
Top stories. INC updates. CNE opportunities. 5-minute read.
Double opt-in via Brevo. Unsubscribe anytime.
Read our Editorial Policy · Corrections Policy · Fact-Checking Policy
References
- 1.Denying study leave to nurses for PG courses while allowing doctors is discriminatory: HP HC
- 2.HP High Court: denial of study leave to staff nurses despite grant to Medical Officers is discriminatory
- 3.Archna Thakur v. State of H.P., CWP No. 18264 of 2026 (judgment, 15 Oct 2026)
- 4.Staff nurses cannot be denied M.Sc Nursing study leave when others are granted same benefit
- 5.CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972, Chapter VI: Study Leave (Rules 50-51)

PM Modi Spotlights Biotech, Yoga, and Medical Heritage at 'Bharat Innovates' Launch in France
Highlighting India's historical legacy in medicine and its booming startup ecosystem, the Prime Minister called for global collaboration in biotechnology and human-centric healthcare innovation.
3 min read


